The Gift I Didn’t Get

Summary


"The Gift I Didn't Get" is a charming Christmas poem in which the speaker reflects on a pile of holiday gifts from family and friends — yet can't stop thinking about the one present he never received. With warm humor and a light romantic undercurrent, the poem builds to a playful reveal: the most cherished "gift" is a frosty little mitten — a rebuff from a woman he called on, whose cold gesture paradoxically fills him with joy and sets his heart racing.

Read Online

I have presents by the dozen,
Meant to make my Christmas glad,
From each uncle, aunt, and cousin —
Best a fellow ever had.
There’s a keepsake from my mother,
Father sent a check, and yet
I am thinking of another —
Of the one I didn’t get.

There are gifts from all the fellows,
Pipes and things a chum will send;
There’s a tie, all reds and yellows,
From a girl who calls me friend.
You would think me far from slighted
If you saw them all — and yet
I confess, I’m most delighted
With the one I didn’t get.

She told me it was ready,
She’d prepared it long before;
I’d been calling on her steady
For at least a year or more.
She told me all about it,
And her eyes with tears were wet;
And I’m happy, never doubt it,
For that gift I didn’t get.

A young man receives a frosty mitten at a snowy doorstep in "The Gift I Didn't Get"

Her attitude was altered
When I called on her last night;
But my tale of love I faltered —
And I guess I did it right.
And this little rhyme is written —
‘Cause I’m full of joy, you bet! —
For a frosty little mitten
Was the gift I didn’t get.

Credits

Peter McArthur was a Canadian writer and humorist active in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, best known for his witty essays and light verse. This poem showcases his signature blend of dry humor and sentimental charm, using the Christmas gift-giving season as a backdrop for a gently comic tale of courtship.